Our Gallery

Discover the artistry behind our authentic coal-fired pizzas, the warmth of our restaurant, and the memorable moments we create together

800°F

Coal Oven Temperature

24

Years of Excellence

50+

Specialty Pizzas

Browse Our Photos

coal fired margherita pizza with fresh basil

Classic Margherita

Fresh mozzarella, San Marzano tomatoes, and basil

pepperoni pizza with coal fired char

Pepperoni Classic

Our signature pepperoni with perfect coal-fired char

white pizza with ricotta and garlic

White Pizza Delight

Ricotta, mozzarella, garlic, and olive oil

supreme pizza with multiple toppings

Supreme Special

Loaded with pepperoni, sausage, peppers, and more

coal oven flames cooking pizza

800°F Coal Oven

The heart of our authentic cooking process

fresh salad with italian dressing

Garden Fresh Salad

Crisp greens with our house Italian dressing

cozy restaurant dining room with warm lighting

Main Dining Room

Warm and inviting atmosphere for families

open kitchen with coal oven visible

Open Kitchen

Watch our chefs create your perfect pizza

bar area with craft beer selection

Craft Beer Bar

Perfect pairings for your meal

outdoor patio seating area

Outdoor Patio

Al fresco dining in beautiful Pine Plains

birthday party celebration in restaurant

Birthday Celebrations

Making special moments even more memorable

family gathering around large pizza table

Family Gatherings

Bringing families together over great food

pizza making class with chef

Pizza Making Classes

Learn the art of authentic pizza making

community fundraiser event

Community Events

Supporting our Pine Plains community

Ready to Experience Anthony's?

Join us for an unforgettable dining experience with authentic coal-fired pizza

Explore our menu Make a reservation